4 Tips for Hiring the Right Creative Agency

Spin Creative • April 1, 2020

When you hire a creative agency on retainer, you’re doing more than securing extra help with your marketing. 

A neon sign that says craft on it
You’re forming a partnership with a team who is excited to help your business grow. Just like hiring the right employees for your team is a crucial step, you also need to be discerning when hiring a creative agency to develop your brand’s identity. 

Here are four tips for hiring the right creative agency for your business. 

1. Get to know the team
Although you may only talk to one or two representatives from your creative agency regularly, many people could be working on your creative campaign. It’s a good idea to get to know who it is you’re trusting with your brand. 

Make sure that the people you meet are the people you’ll be working with on your campaign. If the agency outsources any piece of the work, ask about that process. If you can’t all meet in person, ask for an introductory video call so that you can get a sense of the team’s personality and working style. 

2. Ask about the agency’s structure
Hiring a creative agency on retainer is an excellent way to find a creative partner while saving time and money. Before you lock into a partnership ask questions about the company so that you can better understand how your business fits into their broader ecosystem. 

Some questions you may want to ask when hiring a creative agency include:
• How are account teams structured?
• Are there account limits on how much a team member can work on one client?
• What work is each team member responsible for?

The agency may make it sound like they’re completely committed to you, when in reality they don’t have enough staff to cover their current clients. Don’t be afraid to ask questions when interviewing an agency. 

3. Learn their KPIs
Your idea of success may differ from your creative agency’s definition. How does the agency track and measure results?

You want to be able to see quantitative evidence that your investment is making a difference. A good creative agency is equally committed to seeing your marketing and branding improve and will be eager to share the data with you. 

How you and the agency measure success will naturally vary by campaign and change over time. Some campaigns may be driving a particular product line while others are focused on increasing brand awareness. It’s important that your creative agency remains flexible in helping you to achieve and to track these goals. 

4. Know your needs
The tips above won’t matter much if the creative agency you’re interviewing is a complete mismatch for your vision. If you’re not sure what you’re looking for from your creative, the professionals at the agency will be able to help. But if you know you want something specific – like a digital video campaign – and the agency doesn’t have a video team, you don’t need to bother. 

The creative landscape is changing quickly, and you want to hire a creative agency on retainer who can help you grow and adapt. That’s why the professionals at Spin Creative are here for you. Say hello!


About Us
Spin Creative is a video production company and creative agency helping marketers create winning video and creative strategies that engage, inspire and activate targeted audiences. Spin is headquartered in Seattle with offices in San Francisco and London, serving brands around the globe.
Pastel 3D social media chat icons and message bubbles on a pink background
By Spin Creative July 5, 2026
Transform complex enterprise products into compelling stories. Learn why clarity, not complexity, is the competitive advantage that builds stronger brands and drives growth.
Pastel blue and orange rectangular boxes arranged in a row on a light gray surface
By Spin Creative June 22, 2026
Learn how enterprise marketing teams create brand clarity through strategy, messaging, design, motion, video, and activation. Explore Spin Creative's branding approach.
Pink clouds at sunset with a flock of birds over a dark horizon
By Spin Creative June 16, 2026
What can a flock of birds teach us about marketing? Discover why insight is the foundation of effective branding, storytelling, creative strategy, and memorable customer experiences
Colorful pie charts scattered on a light background, showing assorted chart segments in red, yellow, blue, and black.
By Spin Creative June 10, 2026
In a crowded marketplace, the brands that stand out aren't louder. Learn how brand differentiation, storytelling, and clarity create lasting advantage.
Show More